Comments on: Cover Me in Wild Horses: From The Rolling Stones to Susan Boyle

By: Lucacentric

Lucacentric — Sat, 12 Dec 2009 20:54:04 +0000

I think that Susan’s cover of “Wild Horses” is one of the best things about the whole album. She could do a whole disc of rock cover tunes and it would be amazing. Did anyone hear about the Susan Boyle special on the TV Guide channel Sunday the 13th? Here’s a link to a clip for it: http://www.tvguide.com/special/susan-boyle/

By: fivegoldstars

fivegoldstars — Fri, 02 Oct 2009 10:44:58 +0000

Andrew – in advance, if you do genuinely have special needs, I apologise for treating your comments with the same level of contempt that I would reserve for a normal persons.
Do you understand the meaning of the phrase ‘Lies, damn lies and statistics’? It shows that statistics can be used to prove any point if manipulated correctly.
Susan Boyles version of Wild Horses is officially the worst version of the song ever, as determined by a poll. 100% of the respondents agreed. Now, I was the only respondent, and my opinion was known prior to the question being asked, but the result could be quoted as proof of the above statement.
The only people who voted in those polls that you mention, the only people who are bothered about fueling this musical farce, are precisely the same people who voted for her in BGT, and the type of people who should not be allowed to vote in any contest, referendum or election. That is why the results are null and void.
Also, please clarify this strange comment about ‘made up stories’. Is the article above not simply a review, which uses personal opinion to offer up alternative opinion? Do all reviews or critiques have to match your own view? If so, maybe we’d all better invest in one of those special helmets.

By: andrew burns

andrew burns — Fri, 02 Oct 2009 05:20:09 +0000

Lies,damn lies and statistics.Strange point of view considering you assume who you believe voted in them polls.When on the defence only way back is to attack ,but in your case you had nothing to attack with so you just made up whatever came into your head, Not a very smart move for someone who is supposed to be educated is it.Oh,and by the way ,Mick jagger has called the version ghostly and better than anything he has ever done.More lies and statistics eh.You need to learn how to do research,Unless of course typing made up stories turns you on,Perhaps your mom should have called you hans christian anderson.You sure tell better stories than he ever did.

By: fivegoldstars

fivegoldstars — Fri, 25 Sep 2009 07:19:06 +0000

Andrew, Andrew, Andrew. Where do I begin?
1) ‘Fivegoldstars’ is a pen name which has been chosen in homage to something other than my literary prowess. Google LFC, you’ll find the answer.
2) Sympathy got Susan to the runners-up spot – winning it would have just required more sympathy and from a greater number of phone-wielding idiots.
3) Lies, damn lies and statistics? Who do you think voted in those polls? I refer you to point 2.
4) Please do not criticise someones writing ability and then misuse the word ‘their’. It makes you look silly. Or, go to point 2.

By: Andrew Burns

Andrew Burns — Fri, 25 Sep 2009 02:13:50 +0000

Am astonished you call yourself fivegoldstars, Not many would give you 1 star for that nonsense you have typed. If sympathy was the only reason for listening to susan boyle then she would have won Bgt. And a world class singer will be chosen if they look like a goddess or a garbage can so that is a totally ridiculous comment to make, And this overated singer has been described by the top 20 vocal coaches in the usa as an outstanding talent. And finally. On rolling stone magazine they have a debate as to which is the greatest version of all time. Current score: Susan Boyle 251 the rest 49. And on Virgin website 96%: to 4%: out of 500 that voted. And acknowledged by music critics around the world as an outstanding version.Now let me see there opinion or yours, Not even close is it.

By: fivegoldstars

fivegoldstars — Sun, 20 Sep 2009 17:33:06 +0000

Thanks for the comment Sheryl. I’d just like to point out that Boyles appearance has no bearing on my opinion of her – my favourite Christmas track is by The Pogues! Personally, I think that her lack of looks is the most exploited commodity of all – if her voice came from an 18 year old blonde bombshell, would people be lavishing as much praise on her? The public likes an underdog, and I find some of Boyles support to be bordering on patronising.

By: Sheryl

Sheryl — Sun, 20 Sep 2009 15:57:19 +0000

Why are some people so cynical? Come on now – Susan Boyle was just like any of the others that audition for these talent shows – inexperienced, naive, etc. The only thing that makes her different than most – she’s awesomely talented! I’m so grateful for these shows that make it possible for us to find these people, hidden jewels of incredible talent. Sorry, but I’m quite sick of the gold digging backers – they find the next young bombshell that they can put into skin tight rubber outfits, with garter belts and 10 inch heeled boots, add some all-but x-rated video to cover up the weak talent – and a star is born! Susan’s version of wild horses gave me goosebumps and brought tears to my eyes – what I would give to be able to sing like her! Her critics are visual versus audio listeners, let’s hear some of these new artists belt out a song like that without their sleezy Las Vegas act to distract us. What Susan has is a voice from heaven and I’m so thrilled that it’s been brought to the public and shared with those of us that are inspired by the beauty of a voice. The hype behind Susan Boyle is simple – she’s become a superstar because of her voice. It’s that simple. I will absolutely buy her CD and will glady pay to see her sing, not perform, but sing!

By: fivegoldstars

fivegoldstars — Sat, 19 Sep 2009 14:51:06 +0000

Thanks for the comment CS. Am I to understand that every review or critique should be glowing, sycophantic praise? The article was intended to inform the karaoke TV generation that there is other music out there – from talented, hardworking musicians. Whilst I may be negative about the over exposed Ms Boyle, I have high praise for the other five artists mentioned, along with the original writers/performers.

By: C S

C S — Sat, 19 Sep 2009 13:44:16 +0000

Quit complaining and just don’t listen. Won’t that be easier and less strenuous, or do you just require an outlet for your obvious high level of negativity??? Susan’s versions is the first I have ever bought.

By: fivegoldstars

fivegoldstars — Fri, 18 Sep 2009 16:35:44 +0000

True enough, and my sentiments exactly. Unfortunately, without writing the article, and raising her name, I wouldn’t be able to criticise the cover.